Experts recommend you repair when your damage is localized to components like seals, bearings, or minor internal components, if the housing/case is undamaged and downtime permits a teardown.
Replacement makes sense when a catastrophic planetary gear failure occurs, the outer case or main shaft is destroyed, metal contamination has flooded the hydraulic system, or minimizing machine downtime is the top priority.
In this Shop Talk Blog post, let’s talk about why this approach is recommended.
-
1. Perform a 4-Step Diagnostic Check Before Deciding
Before jumping to replacement, evaluate the drive using four critical factors: extent of physical damage, estimated downtime, total repair costs, and remaining machine lifecycle.
-
2. Minor Issues Are Candidates for Repair
If damage is isolated—such as worn face seals, minor bearing wear, or simple hydraulic leaks—repairing or rebuilding the motor is usually the most cost-effective option.
-
3. Catastrophic Internal Damage Warrants Full Replacement
When severe damage occurs—like shattered planetary gear sets, cracked main housings, or total piston metal-on-metal lockups—replacement is safer, faster, and cheaper than replacing individual internal components.
-
4. Factor in the Cost of Downtime, Not Just Parts
A new or remanufactured final drive motor ships immediately, eliminating expensive jobsite downtime compared to waiting days or weeks for shop tear-downs and specialized parts.
When a final drive motor fails, the work it was doing literally comes to a stop. That downtime is expensive in more ways than one: there’s the lost productivity, repair costs, the potential for missed deadlines, and even the possibility of losing customers. That means one approach to determining if you should repair or replace a final drive is how much downtime you can absorb.
If you have plenty of time and the damage isn’t severe, you can repair your final drive motor. However, if time isn’t on your side or the damage is extensive, then you should probably be looking at a replacement final drive motor. And remember, there are some types of damage that just can’t be repaired. We usually refer to that kind of issue as a catastrophic failure.
